1. Submit privately
Apply for author membership, then upload your PDF after approval. The submission remains private to you and the authorized editor during screening. Membership approval gives access to submission; it does not imply acceptance of a paper.
2. Receive an initial editorial assessment
The first submission report and response letter are free. The report should summarize the author’s objective, explain the basis of the assessment, and identify substantive gaps or concerns with enough specificity for the author to understand them. Presentation preferences should be distinguished from issues that prevent further consideration.
This is an initial editorial assessment, not a claim that independent peer review has been completed. The editor is responsible for the report and decision. The editor may use AI assistance, including scheduled preparation of draft assessments through protected access to manuscripts and review history. Prepared correspondence is saved as a private editorial draft. Drafts are checked by the editor before an author response or decision is issued; they are not independent external peer review.
3. Automatic preprint posting
With your explicit consent to publish the exact uploaded PDF, a new submission is posted automatically after a language check. Flagged or unreadable PDFs remain private for the editor to check. No separate author message or editorial review decision is required at this stage. The public record identifies it as a preprint; public availability is not certification of its findings or acceptance into a journal issue.
4. Participate in review and revision
The editor may invite corrections, proceed to further review, or decline the manuscript with reasons. An invitation to revise should identify what remains missing and the conditions for reconsideration. There is no guaranteed outcome or fixed turnaround; review depends on the work and reviewer availability.
Submit corrections and your point-by-point response in the same private manuscript workspace. Ordinary invited resubmissions are free. For an existing public preprint with your consent, each revised manuscript PDF you upload automatically becomes the current public preprint. Confirm that you have checked the exact revised PDF and have all authors’ permission. Earlier versions, response letters, reports, and source files remain in the private history. Manuscripts still in private screening require editorial selection and release; accepted journal articles use a separate correction process.
5. Receive a recorded acceptance decision
For new submissions, journal publication follows completed review and editorial acceptance. The record identifies the review basis, responsible editor, decision and date. Additional reviewer details, a custom public summary and conflict-management notes are optional form fields. Existing review correspondence remains in the record; relevant conflicts must still be disclosed and handled. Reviewer names supplied privately are not automatically public. Authors cannot provide independent review of their own work. The editorial policies explain the founding issue’s distinct status.
Optional help with a revision
The free report explains the concerns and outstanding requirements. Detailed help developing an argument, working through corrections, or editing the manuscript is available by separate written quote. Authors may revise independently or obtain help elsewhere. Buying a service is never a condition of reconsideration or acceptance.
Questions or disagreement
If a report misstates your objective, overlooks material in the manuscript, or contains a factual error, explain the issue in your manuscript correspondence and identify the relevant passage or evidence. You may request reconsideration. For a process concern, contact the editor; a reasoned disagreement does not by itself disqualify a submission.
Support stays separate from decisions.
Voluntary gifts and optional services do not affect review priority, acceptance, or publication priority. No gift is expected from an author.