Review and journal acceptance
JOATP welcomes alternative theoretical physics and evaluates the clarity of its claims, mathematical and physical reasoning, engagement with existing work, and reproducibility. A novel proposal is not treated as established physics merely because it is published.
New journal articles require completed review and an editorial acceptance decision. The acceptance record identifies the review basis, responsible editor, decision and date. Additional reviewer details, a custom public summary and conflict-management notes are optional form fields; the existing review correspondence remains part of the record. A blank summary produces a short acceptance notice. Blank fields do not certify external review or absence of conflicts. Relevant conflicts must still be disclosed and handled. Reviewer identities supplied privately are not automatically made public. The author can respond and revise; revisions and response letters are uploaded to the same manuscript’s private workspace. Earlier files remain in its correspondence history. For an existing public preprint with author consent, each new author-uploaded revised manuscript PDF automatically replaces the current public preprint. A manuscript still in private screening requires editorial selection and release. Accepted journal articles use a separate correction process.
Authors must not serve as the independent reviewers of their own work. A founding editor’s later submissions require independent assessment and a disclosed process for handling the editor’s conflict.
Our acceptance criteria, formatting guidance, and review process explain the basis for consideration. Reports should assess the paper’s stated objective, identify substantive concerns, and separate required corrections from presentation preferences. Authors may request reconsideration of a decision with specific reasons and supporting evidence.
The founding issue
Volume 1, Issue 1 is an editorially selected collection of Todd J. Desiato’s research, including coauthored work with Riccardo C. Storti. This founding selection is an exception to the review process for new submissions: its recent author manuscripts are not represented as independently peer reviewed by JOATP. Legacy articles retain their original publication credits and version descriptions. Listing a previously published work does not claim a new first publication.
Membership and preprints
Everyone may read hosted journal papers and public preprints without joining. Signing in establishes an account; an editor must approve author membership before manuscript uploads are permitted. Scope, conduct, and authorship concerns may lead to a declined or suspended membership.
Uploaded manuscripts remain private to the submitting author and editor during screening. A new preprint is posted automatically after a language check when the author has explicitly consented to publish the exact uploaded PDF. Flagged or unreadable PDFs stay private for the editor to check. This automated text check is limited to language screening and does not assess scientific merit. The submitting author must check that PDF and confirm coauthor permission. LaTeX and Word sources remain private; JOATP does not publish or automatically convert them into preprints. Preprint screening is not peer review or journal acceptance. Public pages show the current status.
Authorship, rights, and disclosure
Submit only work you are authorized to share, with the consent of all coauthors. Authors retain their rights and grant permission for JOATP to host and publicly display the submitted manuscript after screening. No Creative Commons license or transfer of copyright is assumed for new submissions. Where an archived work has an existing license, its article page identifies that license; the Estes Park proceedings extract is shared under CC BY-SA 4.0. Rights associated with earlier publisher versions remain with their respective rights holders.
Disclose relevant prior publication, funding, conflicts, and substantive AI assistance. Authors remain responsible for every claim, citation, calculation, and file they submit. Editorial review must consider those disclosures. They may be supplied in the manuscript or covering message. A formal reference list, acknowledgments, and a separate declarations page are encouraged, not compulsory; necessary attribution remains expected.
Corrections and withdrawal
Contact the editor to correct an article record or arrange a revised version. Authors can withdraw their uploaded manuscript through the dashboard. Once a publicly posted manuscript is withdrawn, its public record remains labeled withdrawn and its file is no longer publicly served. Copies previously downloaded by readers cannot be recalled.
Submission, services, and voluntary gifts
Submission, the initial editorial report and response letter, and ordinary invited resubmissions are free. No gift or purchase is required for consideration.
Optional author services are quoted separately. Scope, price, delivery, and cancellation or refund terms must be supplied with the quote before payment. Payment does not affect editorial acceptance or review priority. A person providing paid substantive development assistance must not be treated as an independent reviewer of that work. The editor verifies payment with the hosted provider before marking a service paid. For a billing concern or refund request, contact the editor with the service reference.
Voluntary gifts through PayPal or Zelle support the journal’s work. They do not purchase services or confer review priority, publication priority, favorable assessment, or acceptance.
Paper statistics and public reviews
Paper lists show reads, member up votes, and displayed community reviews. Reads count paper-page openings, with repeat visits deduplicated per reader per Eastern Time day where identifiable. A random browser identifier is stored locally for anonymous read counting; the database stores its hash, or a hash of the signed-in account identifier. Known bots and identified author visits are excluded. Anonymous counts are approximate. Up votes are limited to one per member per paper. Activity dates and counts are retained for graphs; aggregate author statistics are private to that author.
Signed-in members can submit a community review containing their name, optional degree, institution and position, subject, and comments with optional basic rich-text formatting. Only supported text formatting and ordinary web links are retained; scripts and embedded content are not published. Existing plain-text reviews remain readable. These submitted details are public when the review passes language and spam screening and is displayed. The paper’s author can display or hide individual reviews; hidden and held reviews remain private to the author and editor. Displayed reviews are an author-selected collection. Community reviews and up votes do not certify scientific correctness, independent peer review, or journal acceptance. Existing private editorial correspondence is not published through this feature.
Privacy
Sign-in supplies an account identifier and contact email. Your membership application adds your name, optional affiliation, and research statement. JOATP stores those details, submitted PDFs and metadata, editorial decisions, private correspondence and attachments, editable LaTeX or Word sources, manuscript revisions, and service requests so the editor can operate membership, review, and publishing.
The editor can read applications and private submissions. Private manuscript correspondence, letters, reports, and earlier manuscript versions are accessible only to the submitting author and authorized editor. Editable sources are private attachments, and the website does not compile LaTeX. When a manuscript is already a public preprint with author consent, uploading a revised manuscript PDF automatically makes that exact PDF the current public preprint. The upload form states this before submission and requires the author to confirm permission for the revised PDF. Revisions to manuscripts still in private screening remain private until editorial selection and release. Previous versions remain in the private history. After release, a paper’s title, authors, abstract, keywords, PDF, public review summary, and publication status are visible to everyone. Account email, membership statement, private editorial notes, payment references, and reviewer identities are not displayed publicly.
Hosted payment providers handle payment details under their own policies. JOATP keeps the quoted amount and the editor’s payment-verification reference, not card numbers. The editor may use AI assistance to review manuscripts and prepare draft correspondence, including scheduled draft preparation. The dedicated review connection is restricted to the primary editor’s authenticated account and can read manuscripts and review history and save private editorial drafts. It cannot send author responses or change review outcomes or publication status. Drafts remain private to the editor until the editor explicitly shares them. The editor checks the findings and retains responsibility for author responses, acceptance and publication; no AI-generated assessment is represented as independent external peer review.
Contact todd@joatp.com to request a correction, account closure, or deletion of private application data. Public scholarly records and records necessary to resolve a payment or publication dispute may need to be retained; the editor will explain what can be removed.
Volumes, issues, and versions
JOATP uses annual volumes, with articles added as they are accepted and published. The founding issue, Volume 1, Issue 1, opened in October 2026 and remains open through 20 November 2026. Papers accepted and published during this founding period belong to Issue 1. Later issue periods will be identified in their issue records; they are not assigned solely by the calendar month during this founding period.
An article belongs to the issue for its first journal publication date. Later revisions retain that issue assignment and are identified by version and revision date. Public preprints are separate from journal issues.
Contact and publication identifiers
Founding editor: Todd J. Desiato. Correspondence: todd@joatp.com.
The ISSN application is pending; an assigned identifier will be displayed when issued. JOATP does not currently mint new DOIs. Existing DOI links identify the corresponding original publication or author-deposited manuscript, including ResearchGate records. See About & contact for journal ownership and editorial information.